News

How to Choose a Health Insurance Plan During Open Enrollment

How to Choose a Health Insurance Plan During Open Enrollment

Comparing health insurance plans during open enrollment

Last Updated on November 10, 2026 by VantagePoint

Knowing how to choose a health insurance plan can make open enrollment less overwhelming. The right plan should fit your expected healthcare needs, preferred providers, prescriptions, family situation, and budget.

A lower premium does not always mean lower overall costs. Before making an election, compare each plan’s deductible, copays, coinsurance, out-of-pocket maximum, provider network, prescription coverage, and any employer contributions.

How to Choose a Health Insurance Plan: Quick Checklist

Before choosing or renewing a health plan:

  • Review how you used healthcare during the past year
  • Estimate your medical and prescription needs for the coming year
  • Compare total yearly costs, not only premiums
  • Confirm that your doctors, hospitals, and pharmacies are in-network
  • Check how each plan covers your prescriptions
  • Understand the deductible, copays, coinsurance, and out-of-pocket maximum
  • Review HSA or FSA options
  • Confirm dependent information
  • Submit your elections before the deadline
  • Save your enrollment confirmation

When Is Health Insurance Open Enrollment?

For employer-sponsored health insurance, each employer establishes its own open enrollment dates. Employees should follow the deadlines provided by HR or their benefits administrator.

For individual coverage through HealthCare.gov, Open Enrollment for 2027 coverage runs from November 1, 2026, through January 15, 2027. Enrolling by December 15 generally allows coverage to begin January 1. State-based Marketplaces may use different deadlines.

Employers preparing their organization’s enrollment process can use VantagePoint’s open enrollment checklist for employers.

Review How You Used Healthcare This Year

Begin with your actual healthcare use from the previous year. Review available claims, Explanation of Benefits documents, pharmacy records, receipts, and HSA or FSA transactions.

Consider:

  • Primary care and specialist visits
  • Prescription medications
  • Urgent care or emergency room visits
  • Laboratory tests and diagnostic imaging
  • Physical therapy
  • Mental health services
  • Medical equipment
  • Dental and vision expenses
  • Costs that were not covered by your plan

Identify where your current plan worked well and where it created unexpected costs or access problems. For example, a low-premium plan may have become expensive overall if you needed frequent care or paid a large portion of your deductible.

Past healthcare use cannot predict every future expense, but it provides a useful starting point when comparing health insurance plans.

Estimate Your Healthcare Needs for the Coming Year

Consider what may change during the next plan year. Possible changes include:

  • A planned surgery or medical procedure
  • Pregnancy or plans to start a family
  • Ongoing treatment for a chronic condition
  • Regular physical therapy
  • New or changing prescriptions
  • Mental health or counseling needs
  • Adding or removing a dependent
  • A child aging out of dependent coverage
  • Moving to another area
  • Increased use of virtual care
  • More frequent travel

If you expect frequent medical care, a plan with a higher premium but a lower deductible or out-of-pocket maximum may offer more predictable costs. If you expect limited healthcare use and can comfortably manage a higher deductible, a lower-premium option may be worth considering.

These are not universal rules. The best choice depends on the complete cost and coverage structure of each plan.

Compare the Total Yearly Cost of Each Plan

Do not compare health insurance plans based only on the premium deducted from each paycheck.

Your estimated yearly cost may include:

Annual premiums + expected deductible spending + copays + coinsurance + prescription costs − employer HSA or HRA contributions

Review the following for every plan.

Premium

The amount you pay to maintain coverage, whether or not you use medical services. For employer-sponsored coverage, calculate the total annual employee contribution based on the amount deducted from each paycheck.

Deductible

The amount you generally pay for covered services before the plan begins paying its share. Some services may be covered before the deductible is met.

Copay

A fixed amount you pay for a covered service, such as a primary care visit or prescription.

Coinsurance

A percentage of the allowed cost that you pay after meeting the applicable deductible.

Out-of-Pocket Maximum

The maximum amount you pay during the plan year for covered, in-network services through deductibles, copays, and coinsurance. Premiums and costs for non-covered services generally do not count toward this limit.

When possible, compare three scenarios:

  • A low-use year
  • An expected-use year
  • A high-cost medical year in which you approach the out-of-pocket maximum

This produces a more realistic comparison than looking at the monthly premium alone.

Check the Provider Network

A health plan may appear affordable but become expensive or impractical if your preferred providers are outside its network.

Check whether each plan includes:

  • Your primary care physician
  • Specialists you regularly visit
  • Preferred hospitals and medical facilities
  • Mental health providers
  • Laboratories and imaging centers
  • Urgent care locations
  • Pharmacies
  • Providers near a dependent’s school or college

Use the provider directory for the specific plan, not only the insurance company’s general website. The same insurer may offer several plans with different networks.

Provider participation can change, so consider confirming important providers with both the insurer and the provider’s office before enrolling.

Also check whether out-of-network care is covered and whether you need a referral before seeing a specialist.

Review Prescription Drug Coverage

Prescription coverage can vary significantly between plans, even when the medical benefits appear similar.

For every medication you or a dependent regularly uses, check:

  • Whether it appears on the plan’s formulary
  • Its coverage tier
  • The applicable copay or coinsurance
  • Whether the prescription deductible applies
  • Prior authorization requirements
  • Step-therapy requirements
  • Quantity limits
  • Coverage for specialty medications
  • Preferred and participating pharmacies
  • Mail-order options

Do not assume that a prescription covered this year will remain covered in the same way next year. Formularies, coverage tiers, and pharmacy networks can change.

If a medication is not covered or moves to a more expensive tier, check whether an alternative is available and discuss any medical changes with your healthcare provider.

Understand HMO, PPO, EPO, and HDHP Plans

These terms describe different aspects of a health insurance plan.

PlanHow it generally worksMay be suitable when
HMOUsually requires in-network care and may require a primary care physician and referrals for specialists. Out-of-network care is generally not covered except in emergencies.You are comfortable using a defined network and want more predictable costs.
PPOUsually provides more flexibility to see specialists and use out-of-network providers, although out-of-network care costs more.Provider choice and direct specialist access are important to you.
EPOUsually does not require referrals but generally covers only in-network care except in emergencies.You want direct specialist access but can remain within the network.
HDHPHas a deductible and cost-sharing structure that meets applicable federal requirements. It may use an HMO, PPO, or EPO network. Some HDHPs can be paired with an HSA.You can manage higher upfront costs and want access to an HSA when eligible.

An HDHP is not a direct alternative to an HMO or PPO. A health plan can be both an HDHP and a PPO, for example.

Always review the actual plan documents because networks, referral requirements, and out-of-network coverage vary.

Use the Summary of Benefits and Coverage

The Summary of Benefits and Coverage, commonly called the SBC, presents standardized information that makes health insurance plans easier to compare.

Use it to review:

  • Deductibles
  • Copays and coinsurance
  • Out-of-pocket limits
  • Services covered before the deductible
  • Prescription benefits
  • Referral and authorization requirements
  • Excluded or limited services
  • Coverage examples

The standardized examples can illustrate how a plan may share costs in situations such as having a baby, managing diabetes, or treating a simple fracture.

The SBC is a summary, not the complete plan document. If a detail is especially important, review the full plan materials or ask the benefits administrator for clarification.

Evaluate HSA and FSA Options Carefully

A Health Savings Account and a Flexible Spending Account can both help pay eligible healthcare expenses with tax-advantaged funds, but they operate differently.

Health Savings Account

An HSA is available only to eligible individuals with qualifying health coverage. The account belongs to the individual, unused funds remain available from year to year, and the balance can generally remain with the account holder after changing employers.

When comparing an HSA-eligible plan, consider:

  • The higher deductible
  • Your expected healthcare spending
  • Any employer HSA contribution
  • How much you can comfortably contribute
  • Whether other health coverage affects your eligibility
  • Whether you want to save part of the balance for future medical expenses

Flexible Spending Account

A health FSA is established through an employer. Employees generally make a new contribution election for each plan year.

Before selecting an amount, check:

  • Your employer’s contribution limit
  • Eligible expenses
  • The deadline for using funds
  • The claims submission deadline
  • Whether the plan offers a carryover or grace period
  • What happens to the account if you leave your employer

Estimate your contribution carefully because unused FSA funds may be forfeited, subject to the plan’s carryover or grace-period provisions.

Contribution limits and plan provisions may change from year to year. Review your employer’s enrollment materials and the latest IRS guidance before making an election.

Update Dependents and Personal Information

Verify the information entered for every person who will be covered.

Check:

  • Legal names
  • Dates of birth
  • Social Security numbers, where required
  • Addresses
  • Dependent eligibility
  • Coverage level
  • Beneficiary designations for applicable benefits

If you are adding a spouse or dependent, determine whether supporting documents are required. Gathering them before the deadline can prevent delays or an incomplete election.

Review Everything Before Submitting

Before confirming your enrollment:

  • Verify the selected plan and coverage tier
  • Review the employee premium
  • Confirm covered dependents
  • Check HSA or FSA elections
  • Review employer contributions
  • Confirm the effective date
  • Read required acknowledgments
  • Save or print the final confirmation

After coverage begins, compare your insurance card, payroll deductions, and account contributions with your confirmation. Report discrepancies promptly.

Common Health Insurance Open Enrollment Mistakes

Avoid these common errors:

  • Choosing the lowest premium without comparing total costs
  • Assuming the current plan has not changed
  • Failing to verify doctors and hospitals
  • Forgetting to check prescription coverage
  • Confusing the deductible with the out-of-pocket maximum
  • Ignoring employer HSA or HRA contributions
  • Assuming every benefit renews automatically
  • Waiting until the final day to enroll
  • Not saving the enrollment confirmation

Frequently Asked Questions About Health Insurance Open Enrollment

What should I compare during open enrollment?

Compare premiums, deductibles, copays, coinsurance, out-of-pocket maximums, provider networks, prescription coverage, referral requirements, employer contributions, and HSA or FSA options. The lowest premium does not always result in the lowest total yearly cost.

How do I estimate my healthcare expenses for next year?

Start with claims and expenses from the current year. Then add expected prescriptions, appointments, procedures, therapies, and family changes. Compare how each plan would cover that expected use.

Is a PPO always better than an HMO?

No. A PPO may offer more provider flexibility, but it can also have higher premiums or out-of-pocket costs. An HMO may be more cost-effective if its network includes the providers and facilities you need.

Is an HDHP the same as a PPO?

No. An HDHP describes a plan’s deductible and cost-sharing structure, while PPO describes how its provider network operates. A plan can be both an HDHP and a PPO.

Do I need to re-enroll every year?

It depends on the employer and the benefit. Some elections may continue automatically, while others require an active annual election. FSA elections commonly require employees to select a new contribution amount. Review the instructions provided by your employer.

Can I change my health plan after open enrollment ends?

Generally, elections cannot be changed until the next open enrollment unless you experience a qualifying event or another change permitted by the plan. Notify HR or the plan administrator promptly because deadlines apply.

Choose Your Health Insurance Plan With Confidence

The right health insurance plan should balance cost, coverage, provider access, prescription needs, and financial risk. Reviewing these details before the deadline can help you avoid unexpected expenses and select coverage that better fits your needs.

Employees should contact their HR department or benefits administrator with questions about the plans available to them.

Employers that want to offer clearer plan comparisons, enrollment support, and a more user-friendly benefits experience can contact VantagePoint or call (516) 599-2120.

This article provides general educational information and is not legal, tax, medical, or financial advice. Plan terms and individual circumstances vary.

Vantage Point Assistance: Our support team is available to help you double-check and confirm all enrollment information, offering peace of mind that your coverage is correctly set up.

Conclusion

The open enrollment period is an invaluable opportunity to secure the right health insurance coverage for the coming year. With preparation, careful review, and the support of a trusted benefits partner, you can navigate this process confidently. At VantagePoint Benefit, we’re dedicated to guiding you through each step—from understanding plan options to setting reminders for critical deadlines—ensuring that you and your team are prepared for a successful enrollment season.

If you’re looking for personalized guidance on navigating open enrollment or need additional support, please contact our team or request a demo! Our experts are here to answer questions, provide resources, and help you make informed choices for your health and financial well-being.

Official Resources

HealthCare.gov: Glossary of Health Coverage and Medical Terms

HealthCare.gov: Dates and Deadlines

HealthCare.gov: Your Total Costs for Healthcare

HealthCare.gov: Health Plan and Network Types

Department of Labor: Plan Information

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Get the Latest Trends on Payroll, HR and Benefits

We'll never share your email address and you can opt out at any time, we promise